Cannibalistic capitalism: The paradoxes of neoliberal pension securitization

by SUSANNE SOEDERBERG

Workers have become increasingly dependent on the economic performance of corporations for the value of their retirement savings as pension funds across the OECD area have ramped up investment in corporate stocks and bonds. This phenomenon, known as pension securitization and wrapped in the discourse of the ‘empowerment’ of the worker as a shareholder, has become a defining and highly problematic feature of the neoliberal era. Neoliberalism — and, by extension, securitization — needs to be understood not as an end state but as an ongoing and contradictory process aimed at deepening and widening the marketization of society. This process demands that the manifestations of crises of capital accumulation, including struggles that threaten to delegitimize neoliberal rule, be absorbed or displaced, spatially and temporally. It also necessitates that states and capitalist classes continually engage in the construction, naturalization and social reproduction of highly paradoxical neoliberal accumulation strategies such as pension securitization.

Cannibalistic capitalism captures the processes by which workers’ savings in the form of pension funds feed off both their own increased indebtedness and that of other workers, a condition driven largely by stagnant real wages and unemployment. As has especially been evidenced in the US, which shall be the focus of this essay, due to the dependence of pension funds on high-risk investments, their investment strategies mutilate the value of pension savings with the advent of more frequent and deeper financial crises that serve to wipe out gains made during a speculative run. Instead of serving to weaken cannibalistic capitalism, crises have had the effect of deepening neoliberalisation by allowing financial corporations and their shareholders (which include pension funds) to prey on those dispossessed workers, who, in the absence of a safety net, strive to maintain basic living standards through the credit system.

SR for more