by ROBERT INLAKESH

Since October 7, 2023, a narrative has developed that seeks to explain away Hamas through an argument that holds Israel accountable for creating the Palestinian political party, often implying that the group has also been propped up. Behind what is generally an argument made in good faith are some crucial flaws that expose a gap in the understanding of Palestinian politics.
“Hamas was a creation of Israel”: If you have been paying attention to media, both independent and alternative, since at least the beginning of the Gaza genocide, you have most likely heard this argument. You may have also heard that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “propped up Hamas” in the Gaza Strip as part of a wider plot to prevent the formation of a Palestinian State.
Most of those arguing these talking points are doing so from a good-faith position, often using the information they present in order to dismiss Zionist propaganda talking points. Yet, in doing so, these commentators imply something deeper that is both factually inaccurate and presents Palestinians as eternal victims lacking any real autonomy.
In order to get to the bottom of this issue, we must first look at the arguments given to justify the claim that Hamas was a creation of Israel and what the facts truly show. Then analyze the implications of the claim being made, also assessing whether these allegations hold up to reality.
Was Hamas Funded by Israel?
Hamas, which is an acronym for Harakat al-Moqowama al-Islamiyya (The Islamic Resistance Movement), was never actually funded by Israel. The misconception comes from the Israeli relationship with the Mujamma al-Islamiyya that operated in the Gaza Strip.
The Mujamma was a social organization and charity that was created in 1973 by Sheikh Ahmed Yassin. While it was the precursor organization to Hamas, it was very different and the history behind the journey between the two will help explain where the misconceptions arise.
While high-ranking members of the Fatah Party in Palestine – Hamas’ biggest political opponents domestically – the most well put together argument on this topic, presenting the claim that Israel helped create Hamas, comes from well-known journalist Mehdi Hassan. If you look at the evidence he cites, the most compelling source is that of former Israeli Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segev, who was Gaza’s military governor during the 1980s.
After retiring from his role in the military, Segev told the New York Times that Israel had developed a strategy that involved emboldening Islamic groups in order to undermine the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) of Yasser Arafat. He also stated that the “Israeli government gave me a budget” for funding the Mujamma, adding that “the military government gives to the mosques”.
Another source cited is Avner Cohen, a former Israeli religious affairs official, who worked for the occupying army in Gaza and stated that he submitted a report in the mid-1980s to his military superiors that explicitly warned not to play the divide-and-rule game in the occupied territory.
Discussing the Muslim Brotherhood roots of Hamas, in a video published for The Intercept in 2018, Mehdi Hassan makes the claim that once the Israelis occupied the Gaza Strip in 1967, “they didn’t just tolerate these Islamists, they encouraged them”. This is an inaccurate representation and oversimplification of the historical record.
In Gaza, the Mujamma was often referred to colloquially as the “Ikhwan” (used to refer to the Muslim Brotherhood) and was evidently the organization’s Palestine branch. Yet the framing of Israel backing “Islamists” after occupying Gaza during the June 1967 War is factually incorrect. It wasn’t until 1979 that the Israelis officially recognized the Mujamma al-Islamiyya as an organization permitted to operate with the approval of the occupying military administration. In addition to this, not all Muslim Brotherhood-linked “Islamist” groups received Israeli support.
Thinking Palestine for more